If your pool has weak suction, air bubbles, a cleaner that barely moves, or debris that never seems to disappear, the problem often starts before the pump ever gets involved — right at the pool skimmer.
Your skimmer is the front door of your pool’s circulation system. When it’s working correctly, it quietly pulls in surface debris, feeds water smoothly to the pump, and keeps everything downstream operating efficiently. When something goes wrong, it can trigger a chain reaction of problems that look much bigger than they actually are.
This guide breaks down the most common pool skimmer problems, how to identify them, and — most importantly — which exact parts usually fix the issue.
How a Pool Skimmer Is Supposed to Work
A pool skimmer uses suction from the pump to pull water across the surface of the pool. Floating debris enters the skimmer throat, passes through a basket that traps leaves and debris, and then flows through the plumbing to the pump and filter.
Key skimmer components include:
-
Skimmer basket
-
Weir door (flapper)
-
Skimmer lid
-
Vacuum plate (if used)
-
Skimmer throat and housing
If any of these parts fail, suction drops, air can enter the system, and debris control suffers.
Problem #1: Weak or Inconsistent Skimmer Suction
What pool owners notice
-
Debris floating past the skimmer instead of being pulled in
-
Weak pull at the skimmer opening
-
Cleaner losing power randomly
Most common causes
-
Clogged or cracked skimmer basket
-
Missing or stuck weir door
-
Air leak at the skimmer lid or plumbing
-
Water level too low
Parts that usually fix it
-
Replacement skimmer basket
-
New weir door
-
Skimmer lid O-ring or lid replacement
Even a small crack in a skimmer basket can disrupt flow enough to affect suction throughout the entire system.
Problem #2: Skimmer Basket Keeps Floating or Popping Up
What pool owners notice
-
Basket lifting out of place
-
Debris bypassing the basket
-
Rattling or vibration inside the skimmer
Most common causes
-
Incorrect basket size
-
Broken basket handle
-
Excessive suction from the pump
Parts that usually fix it
-
Properly sized OEM or compatible skimmer basket
-
Weighted basket or stabilizer ring (model dependent)
Using the wrong basket is more common than people realize, especially after years of replacements.
Problem #3: Air Bubbles Returning to the Pool
What pool owners notice
-
Bubbles coming from return jets
-
Pump losing prime
-
Gurgling sounds at the skimmer
Most common causes
-
Cracked skimmer lid
-
Dry, flattened, or missing lid O-ring
-
Loose lid allowing air to enter
Parts that usually fix it
-
New skimmer lid
-
Correct lid O-ring (proper size matters)
This is one of the most overlooked air leak sources and often mistaken for a pump or plumbing failure.
Problem #4: Skimmer Weir Door Stuck or Missing
What pool owners notice
-
Leaves washing back into the pool
-
Poor surface skimming
-
Debris drifting away from the skimmer
Most common causes
-
Broken hinge pins
-
UV damage
-
Debris jamming the door
Parts that usually fix it
-
Replacement weir door matched to skimmer model
The weir door is small, inexpensive, and absolutely critical. Without it, your skimmer can’t trap debris effectively.
Problem #5: Skimmer Not Pulling When Vacuuming
What pool owners notice
-
Little to no suction when vacuum hose is connected
-
Pump losing prime during vacuuming
Most common causes
-
Missing or incorrect vacuum plate
-
Poor hose seal
-
Skimmer basket removed incorrectly
Parts that usually fix it
-
Proper vacuum plate for your skimmer
-
Skimmer basket designed for vacuuming
Never remove the skimmer basket unless the system is designed for it — debris can head straight to the pump.
Problem #6: Cracks in the Skimmer Housing or Throat
What pool owners notice
-
Water level dropping
-
Air entering system only when pump runs
-
Wet ground around skimmer
Most common causes
-
Age and ground movement
-
Freeze damage
-
Improper deck expansion
Parts that usually fix it
-
Skimmer repair kit (minor cracks)
-
Professional skimmer replacement (major damage)
Structural skimmer damage often starts small and gets worse if ignored.
Why Skimmer Problems Cause Bigger Pool Issues
A faulty skimmer doesn’t just affect surface cleaning — it impacts:
-
Pump priming
-
Filter pressure
-
Cleaner performance
-
Overall circulation
Many “pump problems” and “filter problems” actually start at the skimmer and work their way downstream.
How to Prevent Skimmer Problems Long-Term
-
Empty the skimmer basket weekly
-
Keep water level mid-skimmer opening
-
Replace brittle lids and O-rings early
-
Never force a basket that doesn’t fit
-
Inspect the weir door regularly
Routine skimmer maintenance prevents some of the most expensive pool repairs.
When to Fix It Yourself vs Call a Pro
DIY friendly:
-
Basket replacement
-
Weir door replacement
-
Lid and O-ring replacement
Call a professional if:
-
The skimmer housing is cracked
-
The deck has shifted
-
You can’t stop air from entering the system
Knowing the difference saves time and money.
Buy Skimmer Parts with Confidence from Benchmark Pool Supply
At Benchmark Pool Supply, we help pool owners every day identify the exact skimmer parts their pool needs — without guesswork.
Whether you need a basket, lid, weir door, or help diagnosing a stubborn suction issue, our team knows what works in Fresno & Clovis pools.
👉 Visit benchmarkpoolsupply.com or stop by one of our local stores for expert help you can trust.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is my pool skimmer not pulling debris?
A pool skimmer is usually not pulling debris due to a clogged or incorrect basket, a missing weir door, low water level, or air leaks at the skimmer lid.
Can a bad skimmer cause my pump to lose prime?
Yes, a cracked skimmer lid or dry lid O-ring can allow air into the system, causing the pool pump to lose prime.
Is it okay to run a pool without a skimmer weir door?
Running a pool without a skimmer weir door reduces debris capture and causes leaves to wash back into the pool, leading to poor surface cleaning.
How often should I replace my skimmer basket?
Most pool skimmer baskets should be replaced every few years or immediately if cracked, warped, or no longer fitting properly.
